Well, I am going to start this one. Maybe it is a bit unfair given that in my position I can get samples from many different shoe companies. But may it is fair in that because of that, my assessements can be real.

First of all, I am a very neutral runner with a high, rigid ankle and arch, one who tends to underpronate.

My recommended shoes should be the Asics Nimbus/Landreth, the Brooks Glycerin/Radius, the New Balance 1062, the Mizuno Rider/Creation, Saucony Trigon/Triumph, or the Nike Pegasus/Vomero.

My favs from this grouping are the Brooks Glycerin and the Nike Vomero. Asics Nimbus and the NB 1062 aren't far behind, but I would lump then together with the Brooks Radius and Nike Pegasus. Of course, your mileage may vary.

Jim